Wednesday, December 16, 2009
SYDNEY: Australia plans to introduce an Internet filtering system to block obscene and crime-linked Web sites despite concerns it will curtail freedoms and won’t completely work.
Adopting a mandatory screening system would make Australia one of the strictest Internet regulators among the world’s democracies. Authoritarian regimes commonly impose controls. China drew international criticism earlier this year with plans to install filtering software on all PCs sold in the country.
The government said on Tuesday it will introduce legislation next year for the filter system to help protect Australians, especially children, from harmful material on the Internet. Critics say it will not prevent determined users from sharing such content, and could lead to unwarranted censorship by overzealous officials. Communication Minister Stephen Conroy said the government would be transparent in compiling its blacklist of web sites, but did not give details. Conroy said the Australian filter was among a number of new measures aimed at strengthening online protection for families. It aims to block material such as child pornography, bestiality, rape and other sexual violence, along with detailed instructions about committing crimes or using illicit drugs.
Such material is already banned from publication on Australian sites, but the government currently has no control over it being accessed on servers overseas. Conroy conceded it may not be completely successful.
“The government has always maintained there is no silver bullet solution to cyber-safety,” he said in a statement. But, “it is important that all Australians, particularly young children, are protected from this material.”
Critics say illegal material such as child pornography is often traded on peer-to-peer networks or chats, which would not be covered by the filter.
“The government knows this plan will not help Australian kids, nor will it aid in the policing of prohibited material,” said Colin Jacobs, vice chairman of Electronic Frontiers Australia, a non profit group that seeks to promote online freedoms. “Given the problems in maintaining a secret blacklist and deciding what goes on it, we’re at a loss to explain the minister’s enthusiasm for this proposal,” Jacobs said in an online posting.
The group is concerned the blacklist of sites to be blocked by the filter and the reasons for doing so would be kept secret, opening the possibility that legitimate sites might be censored. Conroy’s announcement coincided with the release of a report on a months long trial that found Internet service providers were able to block a list of more than 1,300 sites selected by the government without significantly hampering download speeds.
Telstra, Australia’s largest Internet service provider, said blacklisting offensive sites using a filter system was feasible as long as the list was limited to a defined number of web addresses, but that no single measure would make the Internet 100 per cent safe.
“The blocking of a blacklist of sites is one element of the multifaceted approach that is required to create a safer online environment,” Telstra Director of Public Policy David Quilty said.
